The sell behind the SAVE act has always sounded simple: prove you’re a citizen, register to vote.
Read more: The SAVE Act Has a Paperwork ProblemOkay, sure. Citizens are already the only people legally permitted to vote in federal elections.
The problem? Being a citizen and having a neat little stack of documents that prove that citizenship are two very different things.
The Name-Change Problem:
Say your birth certificate says Jane Smith, but you got married and your ID now says Jane Jones. Congratulations, you’re still an American citizen. Your paperwork just doesn’t tell that story in one document.
The legislation allows combinations such as Photo ID plus a qualifying birth certificate. If the current legal name doesn’t match the citizenship document, additional documents might be required to establish identity.
Missing records can make that paper trail longer.
Anyone who changed their surname (for any reason, most commonly through marriage) may need another document linking their current name to the name on their citizenship record.
A trans person whose current legal name differs from the name on their birth certificate can encounter the same basic mismatch, legal name/document discrepancies are baked into the issue. And depending on the person’s documents and state policies, updating those underlying records may itself be complicated.
States would be required to establish a process for people whose documentation has discrepancies, and another process for people who lack the specified documents. BUT, that means the burden shifts from simply attesting you’re an eligible citizen to proving the discrepancy to officials through an additional process.
And it’s not just them
No Passport?
Lost Birth Certificate?
Born somewhere that’s difficult to obtain records from?
Changed your name?
Moved and need to update your registration?
Married women aren’t the loophole.
They’re the easiest example.
Divorced people. Remarried people. Trans people. Adoptees. People who lost documents. People born far from where they currently live. People without passports.
The common denominator isn’t citizenship.
It’s Paperwork.
Just The Facts
21.3 Million Voting Age U.S. Citizens (about 9%) lack or cannot readily access documentary proof of citizenship.
Such as a passport, birth certificate, naturalization certificate, or citizenship certificate.
79% of women in opposite-sex marriages take their spouse’s surname
An estimated 69 million women have taken a spouse’s name and have a birth certificate that doesn’t match their current legal name.
*Note: That doesn’t mean 69 million women lose their vote; many have passports or other qualifying documents.
Many Americans DON’T have a passport
Roughly 146 million citizens are without one.
A valid U.S. passport is one of the simplest ways to satisfy citizenship document requirements.
About 1 suspected case per million votes
Roughly 0.0001% of votes cast are suspected to be from noncitizens.
In 2016, election officials referred just 30 suspected cases for further investigation or prosecution.
A REAL ID generally isn’t proof of citizenship
Most ordinary drivers licenses/REAL ID’s dont establish citizenship on their own
Wait. Isn’t That a Poll Tax?
The 24th Amendment says you can’t make someone pay a tax to vote in a federal election. Critics argue the SAVE act creates a modern version of the same problem: the ballot itself may be free, but the documents you’re required to produce are not.
Need a replacement birth certificate? That costs money.
Need records proving a name change? More money.
Don’t have either? A passport isn’t free either.
For example, in New York, a certified birth, marriage, or divorce record costs $30 by mail or$45 for priority handling. A first time adult passport currently costs $165.
Being a citizen is “free”. Proving it on demand might not be.
Nobody is arguing that noncitizens should vote. We agree; only citizens should. The problem is what happens when “prove you’re a citizen” becomes “prove it in exactly the way we’ve decided counts.” Millions of Americans have messy paperwork, changed names, and missing documents. Their citizenship isn’t any less real because the paperwork is complicated.
Leave a Reply